Café de spécialité en grains mis dans un moulin manuel

Manual vs. Automatic Coffee Grinders: Which is the Right Choice for You?

published on October 19, 2021 — by Marc-Alexandre Emond-Boisjoly — 15 mins of reading —

Choosing the right coffee grinder is a crucial step for any coffee lover who wants to enhance their daily routine. The quality of the grind has a direct impact on the final taste of each cup. Faced with a multitude of options on the market, two main categories stand out: manual grinders and electric grinders. So, which should you choose? This article will guide you through the differences between these two types of grinder, and help you make an informed decision.

Why choose a coffee grinder?

Before getting to the heart of the matter, it's important to understand why it's essential to invest in a coffee grinder. Unlike industrial ground coffee, which quickly loses its aroma once packaged, grinding beans just before brewing guarantees incomparable freshness and quality. Grinding also has an impact on the extraction method, i.e. how the water seeps into the coffee to extract its aromas and oils.

A Good Mill Is Perfect Balance

The aim of a good coffee grinder is to achieve a uniform grind, as uneven grinding can create an unbalanced extraction. Smaller particles may be over-extracted, resulting in a pronounced bitterness, while larger particles may not be sufficiently infused, giving a bland taste. Whether you're using an espresso machine, a plunger coffee maker or a slow-brewing method like Chemex, grinder precision is key.

Manual Coffee Grinders: Tradition and Portability

Manual coffee grinders have been around for centuries. With their simple mechanisms, these mills are appreciated for their durability and ability to produce a precise, uniform grind. Unlike an electric grinder, their operation is based on manual force: simply turn a crank to grind the beans.

Advantages of the Manual Mill

Portability and lightness
Thanks to its compact size, the manual mill is ideal for those who travel. If you like to camp or travel, a manual mill lets you grind your grains anywhere, without depending on a power source.
Durability
Hand mills, often made of stainless steel or with ceramic grinding wheels, are extremely robust. They have few components likely to break, ensuring a longer service life than most electric mills.
Grinding Control
Top-of-the-range manual grinders, equipped with precision grinding wheels, enable you to adjust the grind level with great precision. Whether you're preparing a fine espresso or a piston coffee maker requiring a coarser grind, a good manual grinder will fit the bill.
Less Noise
If you're an early riser and don't want to wake the whole house, the manual grinder is much quieter than an electric one, perfect for early morning use.
Economical
Compared with electric models, manual mills are generally more affordable. You can get a quality mill with ceramic or steel grinding wheels for a reasonable price.

Disadvantages of the Manual Mill

Physical effort and time
Although it's satisfying to grind your beans by hand, it takes time and effort, especially if you're brewing a large quantity of coffee. You'll need a few minutes to grind enough coffee for a single cup, and even longer for a whole coffeemaker.
Limited capacity
Manual grinders have a small hopper for the beans and a small container for the ground coffee. This makes them impractical if you need to grind a large quantity of coffee at once.
Less practical for Very Fine Grinding
Some manual grinders may struggle to produce the extremely fine grind required for espresso. This may depend on the quality of the grindstones and the precision of the adjustment mechanism.

Electric Coffee Grinders: Speed and Convenience

The electric grinder, on the other hand, offers a quick and easy solution for grinding coffee. At the touch of a button, you can get freshly ground beans in seconds. They often feature fine adjustments to control grinding, making them a versatile tool for various types of preparation.

Advantages of the Electric Mill

Speed and efficiency
An electric grinder can grind a large quantity of beans in a matter of seconds. For those who brew several cups of coffee a day, or enjoy brewing methods that require large quantities, the speed of an electric grinder is an undeniable asset.
Ease of use
Simply press a button, and the electric grinder does all the work. You can also find grinders with precise settings that allow you to choose the ideal grind size according to the preparation method (espresso, filter, piston, etc.).
Precision and Uniformity
Electric grinders, especially those of superior quality, produce a very regular grind, which is essential for optimum extraction. Models with conical or flat grinding wheels are capable of producing a very fine grind for espresso, or a coarser grind for other methods.
Large capacity
Electric grinders often feature a larger hopper and a more spacious ground coffee container, so you can grind enough coffee for several cups at a time without having to constantly recharge.

Disadvantages of the Electric Mill

Higher cost
Quality electric grinders can cost several hundred dollars, especially those equipped with high-precision grinding wheels. For coffee lovers who want top-of-the-range equipment, you need to be prepared to invest.
Noise
The motor on electric mills can be quite noisy, especially when grinding grain early in the morning or late at night. This noise can be annoying for some users.
Less Portable
Electric mills require an electrical outlet, which makes them less convenient to transport. They are also bulkier than their manual counterparts, limiting their use when traveling or outdoors.
Maintenance and breakdowns
More mechanical components also mean more potential points of failure. Electric mills require more maintenance than manual mills, and can be costly to repair if they break down.

Blade Mills vs. Millstones: Another Key Factor

When choosing between a manual or electric mill, it's also crucial to understand the difference between blade and wheel mills.

Blade Mill

Blade grinders work like a small blender, chopping coffee beans with rotating blades. Although affordable and easy to find, their main weakness lies in the inconsistency of the grind. The result is often a mixture of fine and coarse particles, leading to uneven extraction and inferior coffee quality.

Grinding Mill

Wheel mills, whether flat or conical, offer a more even grind. Beans are ground evenly, resulting in balanced extraction and better flavor. Wheel grinders are more expensive, but a wise investment for any coffee lover looking to optimize the quality of their beverage.

How to choose the right coffee grinder?

Considerations

Your Lifestyle
If you travel a lot, the manual mill is a perfect companion. If you have a more sedentary lifestyle and are looking for speed, the electric mill is probably your best choice.
Budget
Manual mills are generally less expensive than electric mills. If you're looking for an economical solution without sacrificing quality, a manual wheel mill is a good option. If you're ready to invest, electric mills offer greater convenience and precision.
Preparation method
If you like to vary extraction methods (espresso, filter, French press), an electric grinder with precise settings may be more practical. If you prefer a single method (e.g. French press), a well-tuned manual grinder will suffice.

Conclusion: Manual or Electric, What's Your Choice?

Ultimately, the choice between a manual or electric coffee grinder depends on your priorities: if you prefer portability, silence, and affordability, a manual grinder is perfect for you. If you prefer speed, convenience and versatility, an electric grinder is an excellent investment.

Investing in a coffee grinder is an essential step for any coffee lover looking to enjoy a fresh, tasty cup every day. And of course, good coffee always starts with good beans. Discover our selection of freshly roasted beans at 94 Celsius for an exceptional coffee experience at home!

Tags: Café de spécialité Découverte Recette

Older Post Back to The Coffee Notebook Newer Post